In this paper, you will exercise utilitarian thinking. You should, in your own words, (a) state
what utilitarianism is, (b) state the distinction between act- and rule-utilitarianism. You
should then carry out (c) an act- and (d) a rule-utilitarian analysis of the following case.
There are two people in your hospital awaiting a kidney. There is one kidney available that
will be a match for both of them. They both have rare blood and tissue types that make it
unlikely that another kidney can be found any time soon that might be a match for either so
this might be the last chance for both.
One individual, John, is a 19 year old male college student, a slightly below average student
majoring in business (when he goes to class). He went to a party, something he does often,
and got thoroughly drunk, also something he does often. He got into his car and went for a
drive. Since he was much too drunk to be driving he lost control of the car and struck a
telephone pole. The impact of the crash has caused both of Johns kidneys to rupture. The
kidney transplant will probably enable him to live a normal life if he is careful and stops
drinking. His family is very wealthy and can easily afford to pay all hospital costs. Dialysis
can keep him alive for a few years at most and the procedure will cause steady deterioration.
The second individual, Paul, is a seventy year old retired janitor. He was also the pastor of a
small rural church for nearly forty years, during which time he was held in the highest
esteem, raising money for the poor, presiding over hundreds of weddings and funerals. You
can scarcely tell he is retired since he has remained almost fully engaged in the activities of
the church. However, he has a number of other medical conditions (most notably
arteriosclerosis) that make it unlikely he will live longer than another five years at most. Each
year will probably make him less robust and less able to keep up his remarkable pace. In
addition, he has no medical insurance, and couldnt begin to reimburse the hospital for the
4
costs of his treatment. Dialysis may keep him alive for a year or so, but at his age and in his
condition, it will take its toll.
Who gets the kidney?
Are you looking for a similar paper or any other quality academic essay? Then look no further. Our research paper writing service is what you require. Our team of experienced writers is on standby to deliver to you an original paper as per your specified instructions with zero plagiarism guaranteed. This is the perfect way you can prepare your own unique academic paper and score the grades you deserve.
Use the order calculator below and get started! Contact our live support team for any assistance or inquiry.
[order_calculator]